Court Throws Out $73.5M Cut to New York Over Non-Domiciled CDLs
By Ray Castellano · 2026-11-15 · 6 min read
A federal appeals court on November 13 threw out the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's decision to withhold $73.5 million in highway money from New York over the way the state issued non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit called the penalty "arbitrary and capricious," according to FreightWaves, which reported the decision was unanimous.
It is the first appellate loss for FMCSA in its year-long campaign against states over these licenses. But drivers who hold a New York non-domiciled CDL should not read it as a reprieve for their own credential. The case was about money owed to the state, judged under the old rules. The tighter federal rule written since then is a separate fight.
The case in numbers
| Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Funding FMCSA withheld from New York | $73,502,543 | FreightWaves |
| Share of the state's normal federal transportation funding | about 4% | FreightWaves |
| Fiscal year the cut applied to | FY2027 (began Oct. 1, 2026) | Trucking Dive |
| Date FMCSA notified the state | April 16, 2026 | Trucking Dive |
| FMCSA audit of New York's program | July 2025 | Trucking Dive |
| Non-domiciled CDL and permit holders in New York | about 32,600 (roughly 7% of the state's commercial credentials) | FreightWaves |
| Penalty FMCSA had warned of for FY2028 | double the FY2027 amount | Trucking Dive |
| Panel vote | 3–0 | FreightWaves |
Counts of affected drivers vary by outlet. Trucking Dive put the number of New York drivers with non-domiciled status at about 25,000 based on earlier records, while FreightWaves reported roughly 32,600 licenses and permits. The gap may come down to whether learner's permits are counted; neither figure has been reconciled by the state or FMCSA in anything we could find.
What FMCSA said New York did wrong
FMCSA's complaint was narrow. After its audit, the agency said New York issued non-domiciled CDLs to non-citizens whose permission to stay in the country ran out before the license did. Under the rules in place at the time, a non-domiciled CDL could run five years when first issued and eight years after renewal, the same terms as a regular license. A driver could qualify with an unexpired Employment Authorization Document or a foreign passport with an approved I-94.
In its April letter, FMCSA Administrator Derek Barrs called the state's practice "unacceptable and a significant safety risk," Trucking Dive reported. The agency found New York "substantially noncompliant," cut the funding for the fiscal year starting October 1, warned that the loss could double the following year and raised the possibility of decertifying the state's CDL program. Governor Kathy Hochul called the action "political payback," according to several reports.
Why the court sided with the state
The panel's reasoning came down to one point: the rule FMCSA was enforcing did not say what the agency said it did. According to the reports, FMCSA conceded that the plain text of the regulations in force at the time contained no requirement that a CDL expire when the holder's lawful-presence documents expire. The agency argued that such a requirement was common sense. The court said an agency cannot penalize a state for breaking a rule that was never written down.
The judges also pointed out, per FreightWaves, that FMCSA had never before found any state out of compliance on this basis under the 2011 rule. Reports name Judge Alison Nathan as the author of the opinion.
The penalty process itself is set out in 49 CFR Part 384, Subpart D, which lets FMCSA withhold a share of federal-aid highway funds from a state that does not substantially comply with the CDL program rules. The ruling does not change that power. It says the agency used it on a requirement that did not exist yet.
What the ruling does not change
The current federal rule still stands. FMCSA rewrote the standard, first with an interim final rule in September 2025 and then with a final rule published in February 2026. That rule ties non-domiciled licenses to lawful status and is the reason so many states have paused or stopped issuing them. It is being challenged in the D.C. Circuit, but the court declined to pause it in May, and reports this week say it remains in effect while the case continues.
State actions already taken stay in place. Nothing in the New York decision reverses downgrades, pauses or cancellations by other states. Drivers licensed in states that have stopped issuing or renewing these credentials face the same situation they did last week.
An appeal is possible. The government has not said whether it will ask for rehearing or go to the Supreme Court. We found no statement from DOT or FMCSA on the ruling as of Saturday.
Other states watching
California is the biggest case to watch. FMCSA said in January it would withhold $158 million from the state for the coming fiscal year, according to Trucking Dive, and California's challenge is pending before the D.C. Circuit. Illinois, North Carolina and Pennsylvania have also been cited or threatened with funding losses over their licensing practices. Any state that issued long-term non-domiciled licenses before the September 2025 rule will be reading the New York opinion closely, though a ruling from one circuit does not bind another.
What drivers and carriers should do now
- Holders of a New York non-domiciled CDL: keep doing what you were doing. Check the expiration date on your card and the end date on your work authorization, and know which comes first. The ruling did not extend either one.
- Renewing soon? Expect to be judged under the current federal rule, not the one the court looked at. Bring current immigration documents and allow extra time.
- Carriers: keep license and work-authorization dates in the driver qualification file and flag anyone whose documents expire in the next 90 days. Your annual record review should catch a downgrade, but a calendar reminder will catch it sooner.
- Do not shop for a license. A CDL from a state where you are not domiciled, sold as a workaround, is a fraudulent credential. It will not survive a roadside records check.
- Read the state rules yourself. The procedures states must follow for non-domiciled applicants are in 49 CFR 383.73.
Frequently asked questions
Does this ruling make my non-domiciled CDL valid again?No. It deals only with the funding penalty against New York. If your license has been downgraded, canceled or not renewed, the decision does not restore it.
Will New York get the $73.5 million back?The court set aside FMCSA's funding determination. How and when the money flows back depends on whether the government appeals and how the agency carries out the ruling, and that had not been announced when this story went up.
Does the decision affect the September 2025 or February 2026 rules?Not directly. The court judged New York's conduct under the earlier 2011 rule. The newer rules are the subject of a separate challenge in the D.C. Circuit.
Could California win the same way?Its case raises similar arguments, but it is before a different appeals court, which does not have to follow the Second Circuit.
Where can I find the regulations involved?The state compliance and funding rules are in 49 CFR Part 384, and the licensing procedures for non-domiciled applicants are in 49 CFR 383.73, both on the eCFR.